Questions to Put to a Surrogacy Clinic: The Medical Standards and Canadian Rules Behind Each One

Medical

A surrogacy clinic handles the medical side of an arrangement, and some of what it does follows Canadian law while the rest follows professional guidance. Knowing which is which makes it easier to judge the answers a clinic gives.

What Canadian law sets

Health Canada explains that section 6 of the Assisted Human Reproduction Act sets out the surrogacy prohibitions:

  • It is illegal to pay, offer to pay or advertise payment to a woman to be a surrogate mother, and payment includes cash, goods, property or services
  • Paying a third party, such as an agency, to arrange surrogacy services is illegal
  • Indirect payments, such as covering a surrogate’s mortgage, credit card bills or tuition, are also illegal
  • It is a crime to advise or persuade a woman under 21 to become a surrogate, or to perform a medical procedure to help her become one

Surrogacy itself is permitted when the surrogate acts altruistically. A surrogate may be reimbursed for out-of-pocket costs tied to the pregnancy. Health Canada’s guidance lists categories such as food, maternity clothing, telecommunications, travel, legal and counselling services, and drugs. Lost income requires written certification from a qualified medical practitioner. Every reimbursement needs receipts and a signed declaration, and records are kept for six years.

What professional guidance adds

The American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM) publishes recommendations for practices using gestational carriers. They are US guidance and not Canadian law, but many clinics refer to them. The 2022 committee opinion says:

  • Carriers should preferably be between 21 and 45
  • Ideally a carrier has had at least one term, uncomplicated pregnancy
  • Ideally she has had no more than five previous deliveries and no more than three by cesarean
  • A full medical evaluation is needed, and a uterine cavity evaluation such as a saline-infusion sonogram is highly recommended
  • A qualified mental health professional should evaluate the carrier and her partner or support person before legal counseling and contract signing
  • Infectious disease screening should include HIV, hepatitis B and C, syphilis, gonorrhea and chlamydia
  • Each participant needs independent legal counsel, and a legal clearance letter should be in place no later than the start of the IVF cycle
  • Single embryo transfer is strongly recommended

Turning the standards into questions

Question for the clinic Where it comes from
What are your screening criteria for carriers? ASRM medical evaluation guidance
Who performs the psychological evaluation, and when? ASRM sequencing before legal counseling
How do you coordinate your medical clearance with each party’s lawyer? ASRM clearance letter timing
How do you handle expense reimbursements and records? Health Canada reimbursement rules
What is your embryo transfer policy? ASRM single embryo transfer recommendation

Funding in Ontario

Ontario.ca states that the Ontario Fertility Program allows one additional IVF cycle for a person carrying a baby for someone else. Fertility drugs, genetic testing and storage are not covered.

The Ontario Fertility Treatment Tax Credit covers certain medical expenses paid to or for a surrogate. It is 25% of eligible expenses up to $20,000, a maximum credit of $5,000 per year, for expenses paid on or after January 1, 2025. The goods and services must be provided entirely in Canada and be unreimbursed.

Comparing clinics

Intended parents comparing a surrogacy clinic toronto offers can take the table into each consultation and write down the answers in the same order. A clinic that can explain where its practice follows Canadian law, where it follows ASRM guidance and where it sets its own rules gives a clearer picture than one that says only that it follows best practice.

Where lawyers fit

The ASRM opinion calls for independent counsel for each participant, licensed in the applicable jurisdiction. Health Canada notes that section 6 does not affect the validity of a surrogacy agreement under provincial law. That means the lawyer’s job covers Ontario law, and a clinic’s medical clearance is one part of a larger set of documents.

The takeaway

Canadian law decides what can be paid and who can be asked to be a surrogate. Professional guidance shapes the medical screening. Asking a clinic which standard sits behind each of its practices is a direct way to compare them.